It appears the CME missed Earth, probably to the West and North. It is unlikely at this point there will be any aurora storming tonight.
Northern Lights Now – The CME from the November 5 filament eruption is now expected to arrive at Earth late on Nov 8 and produce G1 storming. SWPC has issued a G1 geomagnetic storm watch. This forecast is lower confidence and more variable than usual. The current predicted timing shows that the period of KP=5 or higher is likely to happen at the end of the UTC day (or just after sunset on the US East coast and around midnight in Europe)
This forecast is low confidence because the majority of the CME is likely to go to the north and west of Earth. If Earth is hit, it will likely be a glancing blow. Further, it is impossible to predict the orientation of the cloud of plasma. If it happens to be oriented with a strong Bz south component, the KP could reach values higher the G1. If it is oriented with a strong positive Bz component, it’s unlikely KP values will read higher than 3 or 4. This is a classic wait-and-see storm.
Here is the WSA-Enlil model output from SWPC. It shows that when the CME arrives, it is likely to have a high proton density. This high proton density, at the same time as increasing solar wind are the primary motivations for issuing the G1 watch (click image for full size):
Northern Lights Now – A somewhat complicated aurora forecast for G1 storming Oct 22nd and 23rd kicks off what may be a long duration aurora event this week. Let’s break it down and help explain why space weather forecasters think this could be an exciting week.
First, coronal hole on the surface of the Sun rotated into the Earth strike zone on October 19. Coronal holes appear as dark areas when viewing the sun through a 211 angstom filter. This particular hole measures in as “relatively small,” but is still 20 times the size of Earth. As coronal holes rotate with the Sun, they track across the Sun’s surface from East to West or from left to right in most images you see of the Sun from satellites. The area near the center of the visible solar disk is the Earth strike zone, when coronal holes are in that area, they send high speed solar wind towards Earth. It typically arrives at Earth about 3 days later, when any disturbances or ripples in the wind have a higher than usual effect on Earths magnetosphere, prompting the possibility of aurora. Here’s an image of the coronal hole when it was in the Earth strike zone on the 19th.
Typically the best chances for aurora are at the time the higher solar wind begins, again after it has been high for a long duration, and finally when a disturbance traveling on the wind arrives. When the wind first arrives, it is carrying additional protons that it has “swept up” as it travels from the Sun to Earth. Those particles were moving towards Earth but at a slower speed. When it arrives, it appears as a sharp change in the solar wind data being read from satellites in a pattern know as an “interplanetary shock”. As the storm continues, it has a cumulative effect on the magnetosphere, “pushing it” as though it is a spring. The more compressed that spring is the more sensitive and responsive it is to regular disturbances that constantly emanate from the Sun and travel along the wind stream.
Most of the time those disturbances are small. Their sources can be seen in the normal movement in the Sun’s corona in time lapse video from sites like SDO. Occasionally, there is a larger eruption either from a flare or a filament that adds to this background activity.
On October 20, one of these larger eruptions took place in the form of a filament on the surface of the Sun erupting from an area just north of the coronal hole. The eruption launched a large cloud of plasma and particles, known as a CME or coronal mass ejection, moving toward Earth. It will arrive at Earth while the magnetosphere is still activated from the high speed wind, and so could produce an aurora show. Filament eruptions like this are stunning! This time-lapse of images from SDO shows the filament erupting over a period of about 18 hours, imagine the material flying out into space and towards Earth.
High solar wind and an arriving CME alone isn’t enough to ensure aurora. The orientation of the plasma cloud has to be just right. As of now, it is impossible to know it’s orientation until the leading edges start arriving at Earth. This means it is difficult to predict the exact timing and duration of the aurora storm. There could be none at all. When it arrives, expect proton density and Bt to increase on the DSCOVR solar wind page. If the Bz goes negative, it means the CME is oriented the right way for aurora if it goes positive or stays positive, there won’t be aurora.
A the tail end of the expected impact from the CME, Earth will fall under the influence of yet another coronal hole. This coronal hole is just rotating into the Earth Strike zone now. This one is much larger. When fully in view it will cover nearly 20% of the solar disk stretching from just south the equator to the Northern Pole of the Sun. This coronal hole has been visible every 27-28 days for the previous three rotations of the Sun. During it’s last rotation it produced 3 days of activity which occasionally reach G2 storming levels. The structure looks similar so it is likely to be equally as strong and have a similar duration. Long term forecasts are predicting there may be KP 5 through the end of the month making this an extremely long period of potential storming. NLN will be continuing to post additional updates on this coronal hole, and any events that happen near it, over the next several posts.
Northern Lights Now – SWPC has issued a G1 geomagnetic storm watch for October 22nd and 23rd due to the enhanced magnetic fields expected as a high speed wind stream arrives at Earth. The high winds are the result of a coronal hole pointed directly towards Earth on October 18th and 19th. The watch means it’s possible that KP values could exceed 4.67 at some point in time on each of the two days the watch is in effect. This same coronal hole was responsible for two periods of G1 storming on September 25th. Here’s an image of the coronal hole:
The current forecast shows the impact of this storm arriving in two waves. First, at onset there may be a shock as the high-speed wind front arrives at Earth. Later on the 23rd, another period of higher KP is expected as the cumulative effects of the high solar wind enhance the magnetosphere’s sensitivity to any disturbances traveling on the wind. In this second period, any prolonged negatively oriented Bz would push the KP higher again. That means the exact timing of the second wave will be harder to predict. Aurora hunters will need to watch the data to know when and if to go out – or as this recent Twitter meme suggests: know when to put your pants on. Here are the current predicted timings from the NLN AuroraCast:
Looking ahead a little, it’s possible to see the edges of the next coronal hole coming into view in the north and east. This is a return of the coronal hole that produced Strong aurora from September 27 to 29. The Sun rotates about once every 28 days, so this means we can expect additional geomagnetic storm watches to be posted over the next couple of days for Sept 24-26. Stay tuned for those watches too.